#59584  by Chuckles
 
How wierd is it that Dylan would turn to Hunter for lyrical collaboration? Dylan is THE definitive lyricist of the last 100 years. Hunter's goo, but... c'mon Bob, whassup? What Dylan needs is a musical collaborator more than a wordsmith, IMHO.
 #59595  by confusions_prince
 
This is where I get to go back to every person who told me (without knowing who Hunter even was or being able to name one of his songs) that Dylan was superior to Hunter and tell them, "eat shit!" This is about the same as Hunter writing most or all of the songs for a Jim Lauderdale album... Hm...
 #59699  by warrenMFKNhaynes
 
Chuckles wrote:How wierd is it that Dylan would turn to Hunter for lyrical collaboration? Dylan is THE definitive lyricist of the last 100 years. Hunter's goo, but... c'mon Bob, whassup? What Dylan needs is a musical collaborator more than a wordsmith, IMHO.

I disagree. It's like comparing Derek Trucks to Jerry. Both amazing, inventive players, but they're too different to really compare.
 #59704  by Pete B.
 
Buddy Cage told me back in Dec '08 that Hunter had written several new tunes (like 7, iirc) for the NRPS, and Nelson was reading/singing them off of a lyric sheet that night.
Cool.
 #59705  by Emoto
 
I wish Hunter would update his online journal that he used to keep at www.hunterarchive.com It was cool to know what he was up to. Has he shifted to another means of randomly informing us, or simply gone silent?
 #59706  by bodiddley
 
krzykat wrote:Hunter wrote silvio for dylan
Was this the only "Grateful Dead" related aspect of "Silvio"? I seem to remember at the time it was released some DJ saying that some of the boys backed him up in the studio, although I've never seen any credits as such. I'm not sure what it is about that song but I just absolutely love the hell outta it. In fact I love that whole Dylan/Dead/Traveling Wilbury's era. Wish they coulda milked it for more. Jerry shoulda been a Wilbury.
 #59713  by confusions_prince
 
Emoto wrote:I wish Hunter would update his online journal that he used to keep at http://www.hunterarchive.com It was cool to know what he was up to. Has he shifted to another means of randomly informing us, or simply gone silent?
Nope, he's just gone silent. I asked him about it. He replied by saying he was on the hottest writing streak of his life and that he didn't have time to (1) update journals or write stories or (2) reply to my email properly. Cast of Clowns, NRPS, Dylan... That does sound busy to me!
bodiddley wrote:
krzykat wrote:Hunter wrote silvio for dylan
Was this the only "Grateful Dead" related aspect of "Silvio"? I seem to remember at the time it was released some DJ saying that some of the boys backed him up in the studio, although I've never seen any credits as such. I'm not sure what it is about that song but I just absolutely love the hell outta it. In fact I love that whole Dylan/Dead/Traveling Wilbury's era. Wish they coulda milked it for more. Jerry shoulda been a Wilbury.
I believe Jerry, Bob, and Brent do backing vocals on Silvio. The easy test is to listen again with that in mind. They all have unique voices.
 #59714  by Emoto
 
confusions_prince wrote:
Emoto wrote:I wish Hunter would update his online journal that he used to keep at http://www.hunterarchive.com It was cool to know what he was up to. Has he shifted to another means of randomly informing us, or simply gone silent?
Nope, he's just gone silent. I asked him about it. He replied by saying he was on the hottest writing streak of his life and that he didn't have time to (1) update journals or write stories or (2) reply to my email properly. Cast of Clowns, NRPS, Dylan... That does sound busy to me!
Thanks for that. I am happy that he's writing a lot. Going to have to check out his new stuff somehow.
 #59726  by Chuckles
 
warrenMFKNhaynes wrote:
Chuckles wrote:How wierd is it that Dylan would turn to Hunter for lyrical collaboration? Dylan is THE definitive lyricist of the last 100 years. Hunter's goo, but... c'mon Bob, whassup? What Dylan needs is a musical collaborator more than a wordsmith, IMHO.

I disagree. It's like comparing Derek Trucks to Jerry. Both amazing, inventive players, but they're too different to really compare.
Yeah... I can see the comparison to Jerry wanting to play with, say, Carlos or Coleman or something. Hard to make an equasion of music idoms to words, but it is definitely in the Beat tradition that they both came out of...

I'll definitely be checking it out...
 #59727  by Chuckles
 
warrenMFKNhaynes wrote:
Chuckles wrote:How wierd is it that Dylan would turn to Hunter for lyrical collaboration? Dylan is THE definitive lyricist of the last 100 years. Hunter's goo, but... c'mon Bob, whassup? What Dylan needs is a musical collaborator more than a wordsmith, IMHO.

I disagree. It's like comparing Derek Trucks to Jerry. Both amazing, inventive players, but they're too different to really compare.
Yeah... I can see the comparison to Jerry wanting to play with, say, Carlos or Coleman or something. Hard to make an equasion of music idioms to words, but it is definitely in the Beat tradition that they both came out of...

I'll definitely be checking it out...
 #59768  by BuddhaG
 
Chuckles wrote:How wierd is it that Dylan would turn to Hunter for lyrical collaboration? Dylan is THE definitive lyricist of the last 100 years. Hunter's goo, but... c'mon Bob, whassup? What Dylan needs is a musical collaborator more than a wordsmith, IMHO.
Hunter was/is so much more concise than Dylan in getting his imagery across. Dylan is a poet but Hunter's words are quite a bit more catchy. Seems like a good combination to me... looking forward to hearing the tunes!
 #59804  by Zack
 
BuddhaG wrote:
Dylan is a poet but Hunter's words are quite a bit more catchy.
That's a bold statement.
 #59809  by amyjared
 
I would love to know how they co-write together. Do they sit in the same room? It is via the internet? Are they outside smoking a phatty and riffing off each other with a tape recorder going? Does one of them do most of it and the other just add a few choice rhymes? What I would give to be a fly on the wall during this collaboration!