Personally I am pretty partial to Mesa Boogie. It's really hard to find an amp that gets you serious tube saturation, including ghost tones, harmonics and all that glorious shit while at the same time it has an amazing vintage blackface tone one footswitch hit away. I can sound like Santana circa 1968, Trey 1991, and sound crystal glassy clean all with just switching the channel selector on the foot board and without needing a drive pedal.
Boogies IMO nail that kind of versatitlity better than anyone. I have a Mark IV combo that I will never part with. Boogies are a tad more complex than most other amps out there, way more complex than a Fender but they are very user friendly in that when you hit a switch or tweak a knob, you can hear the difference immediately. I never said, "hmm, what did that do." You can hear the nuances very easily, so while they are more complex, they are worth the effort and dollars if you are serious about tone.
The versatility of the power amp section of the Mark IV is very impressive, and I had always thought it was the saturation of the power tube section that really gives the amp the growl. Your post seems to be going for something different and maybe you are just looking for a tube pre amp. I could be wrong, wouldn't be the first time, but I definitely LOVE the tones from my Mark IV. Personally I think you have to have tube power and tube pre.
As far as part 2 of your question, depending on who it is, many pros bring an arsenal of amps into the studio with them, or even better they record at a studio with a nasty arsenal of vintage gear in house. A lot of times they will run the signal into a variety of amps, each on its own channel strip so they have the option of listening to all of them in playback and then blending the channels together if they want. It really depends on what you want the guitar track(s) to sound like. I record with a '67 Princeton Reverb for clean tracking, only 15 watts but you can't beat the clean with anything. I also record with the Boogie as it has always sounded much better to tape than my Twin Reverb.
Last edited by Crazy 9.5 Fingers on Mon Aug 04, 2008 6:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.
There are only two mantras. Yum and yuk. Mine's yum.