[razmablues]

Let's say both bands were coming around, and they are both playing on the same night.

Which would you rather see?

[spacehead333]

def rat dog

[rastanewman]

def ratdog now but classic phil with warren and jimmy herring

[krzykat]

Lesh Philling Great Bass

[strumminsix]

gimme the dog please and thank you.

[gratephulphish123]

phish

[krzykat]

phish

thare always has to be one!!!

[kenneybonz]

phil echoing the jimmy warren era
i love it, "classic lesh"

[spilly]

a few years ago I would have gone with Phil hands down, but now, I must admit I'm a bonehead

[shakedown_04092]

Whew....been only a few days since my last post but it seems an eternity (on my honeymoon - had a few minutes to myself, so where else do I go? ha!)

Anyways, it depends on Phil's line-up. If Trey's there, so am I. Other than that, I'm probably more inclined to go to Ratdog, though I've seen a lot more of Bobby in the past 2-3 years than Phil, so at this point in time, it's a tough one. Luckily this year I get to see them both because their schedules don't collide.

[Shaggy]

Who else is playing that night!?

I think I'd go and see Lesh and his crew.

[Larree]

They need to get together and do another Dead tour.

Bobby vs. Phil is so...high school!

It's like... Beatles vs. Stones... Neil Young vs. Crosby, Stills, and Nash... Ritchie Blackmore vs. Jeff Beck!

HAHAHAHAHA

[frankielee]

I AGREE WTH LAREE ...BOBBY..PHIL..BILLY ..MICKEY...COME TOGETHER RIGHT NOW!!!

[justcoophere]

After seeing Ratdog last month for the first time since 2002, I have to go with them. Man, I hate choosing preferences, I wish they were all still in the same band

[gratephulphish123]

know who i wish were still in the same band..... oh forget it you already know