My amateur understanding is that big caps (like in the doghouse hanging below the chassis) electrolytics, definitely do wear out over time, but that others like the tone caps (I forget the proper term; linking caps or something to that effect) do not age badly usually. How much they drift varies widely, and Ive heard that lack of use is actually a higher risk of aging the caps faster. The tone will certainly be different with old drifting caps, but the real danger I believe is when they start leaking and risk causing bigger problems like blown output tranny's. The amp will probably be a lot stronger and better sounding after proper maintainance, especially if the output tubes are weak so it is well worth the time/money, and with a SF there isnt any worry about devaluing its value for resale. As you know components have tolerance variations (e.g. +/- 10%) that I suspect have a bigger (and compounding) affect on the tone than manufacturer for example (at least in the short run). The better caps have tighter tolerances usually. But different construction materials in caps do have different tones I have witnessed.
I think NOS tubes on the other hand can be a step up from the new ones available--although I just saw something about GE manufacturing valves in the USA again. The problem with vintage output tubes is getting strong ones that are matched, they have been picked thru for decades now, like transistors and fuzzes. I have modern JJ's (formerly Tesla) in a Princeton Reverb and Ruby's (Chinese) in a Tremolux and I prefer the tone of the Tremolux greatly. Not sure how much of that is due to the tubes though, but I have heard others give good reviews of the Ruby 6L6GC's in Fender's and AB763's in particular.
If you are using a tech I would be VERY specific about what you want done if you are not close to him and are particular. Techs often get cavalier in servicing amps; rather than just replacing what the amp needs they can just shotgun a whole bunch of stuff at the same time. This inhibits the players ability to know what changes made what difference, and in the case of collectables can destroy a lot of resale value. On the other hand it will cost a lot less to have everything done while he has the amp open--modifications for example.
Last edited by tatittle on Wed Feb 19, 2014 11:53 pm, edited 2 times in total.