I still dont get why people insist that 8/27 is the best show of that year ( or era, or all time for that matter)


caspersvapors wrote:I still dont get why people insist that 8/27 is the best show of that year ( or era, or all time for that matter)I don't know anyone who says its the best of '72- what gave you that idea?
tigerstrat wrote:well people always mention it in the best of all time list, so therefore it must be the best of 72. i agree with you btw, its a SOLID show, but 72 is a rock solid year. and the other thing is people always mention that dark star, but ive heard others from 72 that kick the shit out of that onecaspersvapors wrote:I still dont get why people insist that 8/27 is the best show of that year ( or era, or all time for that matter)I don't know anyone who says its the best of '72- what gave you that idea?
I myself wouold scoff at the suggestion. The Dark Star is ofcourse very heady, as is the GSET, but so much of the show is played OUT OF TUNE, I don't see how it can come close to the many other TRULY BEHEMOTH, KILLER shows of 1972. 7/18, 4/8, 7/26, 10/18, 11/13, 9/21 and many many others absolutely smoke 8/27 as a show imho, not to mention the amazing Dark Stars featured therein which equal or surpass 8/27.

mttourpro wrote:No doubt about that---check out the show from 10 years later as well....I think they referred to it as the Decadenal Reunion or something like that and it was almost exactly 10 years later--8/28/82. FWIW, they also were going to do it again in 92 but I think it was cancelled due to jerry's health problems in fall of 92.. Maybe someone from RUKind was there?? Below is from Setlists.com2nd Decadenal Field Trip - 8/28/82