#34473  by CaptainTrips
 
I really butchered the guitar solo, and I didnt want to leave it as just blank rhythm so I left it, but Id be grateful if you'd check it out. Id really like some input on my singing, and if Ive made any progress from the last tune I posted, TLEO, ages ago. Thanks

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default ... tent=music

Link fixed, sorry about the inconvenience

 #34476  by bobbybobbob
 
Your voice has huge potential. I hear a lot of soul behind it. I felt the pain and heartbreak of the lyrics in there. I think you could get so much more if you "opened up" and sang your heart out, and sang from your lungs. A few times you were out of key, but soo much better then I could have done! I wish I had that "storyteller" voice.

As for the solo- try and stay aware of the timing, and phasing. ver promising.

Thanks for sharing!

 #34481  by GratefulPat
 
i didnt see your version of tleo, but i must agree w bobbbbybbobboob :lol: that you do have a storyteller like voice with great potential, good job

 #34509  by shakedown_04092
 
bobbybobbob wrote:Your voice has huge potential. I hear a lot of soul behind it. I felt the pain and heartbreak of the lyrics in there. I think you could get so much more if you "opened up" and sang your heart out, and sang from your lungs. A few times you were out of key, but soo much better then I could have done! I wish I had that "storyteller" voice.

As for the solo- try and stay aware of the timing, and phasing. ver promising.

Thanks for sharing!
I concur, keep at it man :cool:

 #34516  by Crazy 9.5 Fingers
 
Yeah man, the tone is there in your voice for sure. That is a gift and can't be taught.

What can be taught is breathing properly, enunciation, and learning to control the pitch from wavering off sometimes. I really think with a few vocal lessons your singing could be really great.

I know that I benefited a ton from taking a few lessons from a good teacher. And you have a really nice tone going on, lessons would unlock the great potential that is there.

The voice is an instrument and like all instruments it deserves attention to detail and technical instruction. I think you would be amazed with what a good vocal teacher can do for your voice and singing.

Keep it up!

 #34534  by CaptainTrips
 
I am extremely flattered by the positive comments about my voice. Thanks a lot guys! I always kind of hated my voice. And for a while I just could not sing at ALL! Then I had to just buckle down and really put some time in to get to this point.

But all this encouragement is definitely cool to hear. I will look into taking vocal lessons. I mean I am at the point now where I can buckle down and belt it out, but I know with more work I can get some stuff done.

Again, thanks for the listen, replies and kind words. :smile:

 #34564  by caspersvapors
 
i concur on the voice, it has great potential. if i had your voice Id try to emulate the way this guy sings

http://youtube.com/watch?v=ebWVMV34mJg


I wouldve stuck closer to the way Jerry sings peggy-o though

 #34567  by Billbbill
 
I agree with just about all thats been said. I really like the quality of your voice.

Caspersvapors points you toward fretkillr who is an excellent example. You have a similar quality and the 'comfort with his own voice' and 'ease with which he presents it' are goals you can shoot for.

I actually like some of the different inflection you use.

I expected your lead to make me cringe and it didn't. Almost, but not quite :P Just kidding. You play lead a bit like you sing: Tentatively, with a somewhat stiff cadence. You didn't hit any bad notes, but your timing was stiff. Continue running through those scale patterns until you can do it w/o thinking, at a decent speed, and then let it loose with the same chord change sensibility you display. As your vocal stylings have potential, so does your lead playing.

 #34571  by Mick
 
Lot of agreement from me as well, lots of good stuff there. You did have a few key issues, mostly in the first minute, nothing dramatic after that. Your tone was great pretty much throughout IMO, right around 2 mins, you got up into your nose just for like 2 or 3 words and then got it right back down so you are sensitive to that and reacting really well.

Couple of suggestions, with the forthright admission that I would be darn surprised if I could do as well as what you already posted, and I wish I had as good voice tone as you do: You seem to hurry through the "eeeEEEOOOoooo" parts. Not seeing the music and not being familiar with the song, I am not sure it is realistic, but if you could lengthen these by a half or maybe even a whole beat I think it would make the song sound more laid-back and somber as I believe it was intended. I also think you would do better to "move a little more air", which is kind of hard to describe in a post, but I don't mean sing louder, just project more.

A shot at a better description: I don't think I understood how an acoustic guitar worked until a few years ago, in that I thought most or all of the sound was coming out of the "sound hole". I now realize that is not true, a lot of the good tone that you are hearing is coming from the vibration of the top of the guitar, that has been induced to it through the bridge by the vibration of the strings. This is similar to what I was taught to "project my voice" for public speaking. The idea was to think about "pushing your voice down", meaning into your chest, as opposed to pushing it up into your nose. I don't think I can literally do this, but thinking about getting my chest vibrating, like the top of a guitar, as opposed to my sinus, definitely causes me to project more and makes me sound less nasally. As I said, it sounds to me like you have the "in the nose" problem tackled, so this is just concept so far. I think "moving more air" (those are my words btw) is just my description of loosening the constriction in the throat, which for me at least seems to facilitate the sound coming from lower down rather than in the nose (again, not a problem you have), as well as making pitch control easier. Notice that I said it sounds to me like you need to move a LITTLE more air.

I guarantee the above to be worth every penny you paid for it.

 #34629  by KCJones
 
Oh heck, I'll risk public humiliation and go ahead and ask for a all around critique of my guitar playing on Peggio (aka Fennario). It is me playing the electric guitar part (rhythm and lead) in my former band. There gal singing is also playing acoustic rhythm guitar, and there is actually another electric rhythm but it almost inaudible. So, all the electric you hear is me. Don't pull any punches, including on my "Jerry" tone.

Its one of my Myspace songs: Fennario, KC Moan is up there too.

www.myspace.com/jimmayer

 #34631  by CaptainTrips
 
Im sorry to disappoint, but you'll find no humiliation from me! Or anyone else here I suspect . . .

Beautiful version! I think it started off slowly but really gained speed and took on a life of its own. I wouldnt call your tone very Jerry like however. It rather unique Id say and a little too thin, in my opinion. Not that its a bad thing but its the difference I hear. Jer had a real fat tone going on.

But your playing was solid. I really liked those chromatic runs, although I think they got repetitive a bit . . . but Im stretching to come up with criticism.

Great work.