Let's just say the electronics and the SHH components and their placement were the same as Tiger, of the stock guitars listed above, which would play and sound most like Tiger? Asking for a friend. HaHa. Thank Jerry and thank you all.
Obviously, the major difference is the neck joint, with Tiger and the Gibsons being set necks and a Strat being a bolt-on. As for playing, Tiger is a HEAVY guitar, in the 13 lb. range as I recall! In that sense, the heavier Les Paul would more closely approximate the playing experience. OTOH, the Gibsons are both 24.75” scale, while Tiger and the Fender are 25.5” scale. So in that regard, the Strat would more closely approximate the playing experience.
Bill, tgo