waldo041 wrote:i think pappy's correct in it being an F# on the first conundrum posed.
45:30 to about 45:44
http://www.livestream.com/davidaron/vid ... 5266152479
pappypgh wrote:I'm the one adament about it being an F#, not minor.
I've listened to about 15 different versions from the 80s & 90s. Jerry, without a shadow of a doubt in my mind, hits a major F# chord.
As Tourpro said, I can't provide you with one written shred of proof. But I hear it. If anyone has a video and you can see Jerry's hands at that spot, post it!
It doesn't make musical sense, as the song is in A and the relative minor is F#, I get it. There are many other instances in Grateful-Deaddom that don't make musical sense, either.
Return to Sugar Magnolia
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest